Tucked inside a stately 1906 cooperative on a tree-lined stretch of West 86th Street, a one-of-a-kind duplex is turning heads with its high drama and old-school glamour.
Listed for $3,950,000, this Upper West Side residence offers a prime location, architectural pedigree, and a curated collection of historic New York City artifacts, including hallway lights salvaged from The Plaza Hotel.
The 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath home was originally built as an artist’s studio and still carries that creative spirit. Soaring ceilings, grand windows, and original ironwork offer a theatrical backdrop for the many bespoke design choices inside. From vintage marble and Murano glass accents to black Calacatta marble and a Chesney limestone fireplace, the interior is a carefully balanced mix of past and present.
Located within a classic prewar co-op, the residence also benefits from modern updates and a host of building amenities — including a rooftop terrace, storage unit, and full-time elevator operator — all just minutes from Central Park and Lincoln Center.
Like Fancy Pants Homes’ content? Be sure to follow us on MSN
A great room that lives up to its name
Measuring 27 feet long and nearly 20 feet high, the home’s great room feels more like a grand salon.
A towering double-height window draws in southern light, while two Juliet balconies add romantic flair. Anchoring the space is a striking limestone fireplace by Chesney, flanked by twin Ochre spiral chandeliers that add just the right amount of drama.
Lighting with provenance
Among the most talked-about design features are the hallway lights — once part of The Plaza Hotel’s iconic interiors — now stylishly repurposed in this Upper West Side home. Other unique fixtures and vintage materials were sourced from historic buildings throughout New York City and Brooklyn, giving the home a layered, deeply local personality.
Eat-in kitchen with a vintage soul
The windowed kitchen is as elegant as it is functional, outfitted with handcrafted cabinetry, soapstone counters, and a vintage marble island that serves as both prep space and visual centerpiece.
A six-burner range, Sub-Zero fridge, and wine storage elevate the space for serious cooking, while black and white tiles from Paris Ceramics keep it grounded in classic style.
Vintage details and a jewel box-like powder room
Original details shine in the home’s entry foyer, where the preserved staircase evokes the building’s early-20th-century roots.
A powder room tucked off the entry features luxe finishes including black Calacatta marble, Murano glass accents, and warm brass hardware — a jewel box moment in an already polished residence.
Primary suite with boutique vibes
Upstairs, the primary bedroom suite is an exercise in serenity. Custom built-ins provide ample storage, while the en-suite bath leans into spa-level luxury with Carrara marble double vanities, Ann Sacks fixtures, and a freestanding glass shower.
Two more bedrooms, plus office space
The upper floor also houses two additional bedrooms, a second full bathroom, and a bonus home office — ideal for remote work or creative projects. A washer/dryer is also conveniently located on this level, rounding out the home’s practical touches.
Prewar co-op perks
The intimate, well-managed building offers classic Upper West Side charm with modern convenience. Residents enjoy a full-time elevator operator, a resident manager, a shared laundry and bike room, and private storage. A beautifully landscaped rooftop terrace provides a peaceful perch above the city.
A prime spot on the Upper West Side
Situated just a short stroll from Central Park and Riverside Park, the building places you close to the best of Manhattan. Lincoln Center, top-rated restaurants, and excellent public transportation options are all within easy reach.
Despite being in the middle of it all, the home offers a quiet, refined lifestyle in one of New York’s most storied neighborhoods. Clif Thorn and Jim Testa of Douglas Elliman have the listing.
More stories
Tour a newly listed, $24.95M corner unit in NYC’s iconic One57 building on Billionaires’ Row
Ritz Tower ‘Sky Palace’ commissioned by media tycoon W.R. Hearst for lover Marion Davis lists for $26M
EXCLUSIVE: Pre-War Gramercy Park condo with private terrace wants $4.9M