Switzerland’s initiative to end the “marriage penalty” in federal income tax has lost its lead ahead of the vote on November 29th. In the second poll by gfs.bern for SRG SSR, 54% of those intending to vote said they would definitely or probably reject the proposal, up from 34% in October. Support fell from 55% to 40%, leaving 6% undecided. The shift was sharpest among those certain of their vote. The share firmly opposed nearly doubled, from 20% to 39%.

The Centre party launched the initiative to stop married couples paying more in direct federal income tax than comparable unmarried couples.

Under Switzerland’s current system, spouses are taxed jointly. Adding their incomes together can push married couples with two substantial salaries into higher tax brackets, leaving them with a bigger federal tax bill than an unmarried couple with the same incomes. Married couples with one earner, or with very unequal incomes, often benefit from joint taxation.

Individual taxation, approved in March and due to start in 2032, removes the first disadvantage by taxing each person separately. But some one-earner couples and couples with very unequal incomes could pay more than they do today because they would lose the benefit of joint taxation.

The November 29th initiative aims to protect those couples by keeping joint taxation for direct federal tax, while also guaranteeing that marriage never produces a higher bill. Under the fallback set out in the proposal, the tax would be calculated both ways and married couples would pay the lower amount.

The proposal still commands a majority among supporters of only two parties, the Centre (58%) and the Swiss People’s Party (55%). An initial majority in favour among Free Democratic supporters has given way to 61% opposition. Support also fell among Social Democrats, Greens and Green Liberals. Among voters with no party affiliation it dropped from 61% to 37%. Even among married people and those in registered partnerships, support fell from 65% to 49%.

The proposal retains a slim majority in rural areas, where 51% back it. In urban areas just 36% do. Support fell in all three language regions. It dropped by 19 percentage points in French-speaking Switzerland, to 41%, and by 14 points in German-speaking Switzerland, to 39%. Italian-speaking Switzerland remained the most receptive, at 48%.

Concerns about implementation gain ground
The most popular argument for the initiative was that the tax system should avoid favouring any particular way of life. Some 60% agreed. The proposal would preserve the benefits of joint taxation for married couples with one main earner. Opponents argue that this would give them an advantage over unmarried couples with similar incomes creating a new inequality. Agreement with that objection rose from 36% to 47%.

The most widely supported argument on either side was that the initiative could leave the federal government and the cantons with conflicting tax systems. Agreement rose by 11 percentage points, to 62%. The share who thought the proposal would sharply reduce direct federal tax revenue rose by seven points, to 47%.

More on this:
gfs.bern poll (in French) – Take a 5 minute French test now

For more stories like this on Switzerland follow us on Facebook and Twitter.

Share.
Exit mobile version